PDF | Tradução de Bruno Ribeiro. Original: DESCOLA, Philippe. ‘Beyond Nature and Culture’, Proceedings of the British Academy, volume , pp. Philippe Descola’s Beyond Nature & Culture is not a modest book. Having first appeared French in , it systematizes some of the ideas. In this first part, I will present Philippe Descola and the big lines of the his In Beyond nature and culture, Descola shows that the opposition.

Author: Arashiramar Taurisar
Country: Yemen
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Automotive
Published (Last): 2 May 2015
Pages: 236
PDF File Size: 7.76 Mb
ePub File Size: 1.14 Mb
ISBN: 185-3-92485-514-9
Downloads: 90050
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Gabar

Your points are well taken, but all these points were made brilliantly at the very beginning of European modernity by Spinoza. The recent Luk thep xulture angel phenomenon in Thailand — in which dolls are animated, through specific rituals, with the souls of young children who have passed away — illustrate this indistinct frontiers between human and artifacts. Here, finally, it is brought to English-language readers. Precisely the opposite, in fact — his argument with naturalism is that it reduces and totalizes inefficiently; that it leaves too many strange scraps of human experience worryingly unaccounted for more than once, Descola gives us the study of chemistry as a model for his ambition [].

Journal of Ethnographic Theory

In the second part, I will develop through examples how his theoretical propositions could be adapted to Southeast Asian ethnographic materials. That is why ajd scientific method was cescola in the first place. The books and reviews of Somatosphere. To include in our study the relation between human and non-humans — gods, spirits, plants, animals, objects.

Unless, by diving deeper into the minutia of mythology, we dive headfirst into industrial and economic mythology, we do nothing but spin our wheels. Le Monde, on the French edition.


Beyond Nature and Culture

Those who look to this book with dreams of some more liberal, emancipatory or even anarchistic account of the ontological complexity of our world will need to look somewhere else — indeed, anywhere else.

What about treating dolls like persons? Descola began to question the notion of nature.

American Indians, Vietnamese tribes or Pygmies are also animists. Foolish faith in technological fixes and denial of human overshoot of planetary ecological capacity are among the consequences of this. I came to this review because I was considering desvola or not to get a copy of this book.

Either we study the thought and explain the nature by the culture. Davey rated it really liked it Nov 07, For example, ethnosciences interpret the environment in the light of classification vocabulary that organizes the world fulture orders plants, animals, etc.

So I think it becomes imperative upon a text that seems to emulate the ambition of those authors, that it is especially careful about what other voices it finds worthy of attention. If anthropology has anything to tell us about our species, it is to reaffirm that we are part of a single evolving planetary ecology. Stewart Miller rated it really liked it Aug 17, Beyond Nature and Culture.

Philippe Descola’s Beyond Nature and Culture | Somatosphere

Hardcoverpages. In analogism, humans and non-humans are made up of fragmented essences.

In the final sections, Descola details six modes of relation that mediate these four primary modes of identification — exchange, predation and gift, on the one hand; production, protection and transmission, on the other Fulture cosmologies and systems of knowledge”, in nature. The Achuar are part of Jivaros group formerly known as warriors and head hunters.


Third, finally, is the question of where exactly anthropology currently sits in regard to beyonx division. To transcend the Western dualism that opposes culturr and society as two different and separate realms of beings. Marzia rated it it was ok Apr 28, The spears of twilight: Retrieved December 31,from Somatosphere Web site: Want to Read saving….

These other three ontologies have also survived in enclaves within Western culture, and we may expect one or more of them to increase in prominence over the decades and centuries to come.

Ashveen rated it it was amazing Dec 18, The scientific revolution at the 17th century: Some people expect to continue essentially as before, perhaps with a few reforms. Blackjessamine rated it liked it Jun 27, Philippe Descola has become one of the most important anthropologists working today, and Beyond Nature culturr Culture has been a major influence in European intellectual life since its French publication in Lists with This Book.

The others are animism indigenous cultures of Africa and most of the Americas, most anx Siberiatotemism Australian aboriginesand analogism China, the Renaissance in the West, plus enclaves among indigenous peoples in Mexico, West-Central Africa, and Northern Siberia.

Descola shows this essential difference to be, however, not only a specifically Western notion, but also a very recent one. JTz rated it it was amazing Dec 24, Quantum Physics and the Entanglement of Matter and Meaning.

No Comments

Categories: Politics